Industrial climate targets do not always reflect what companies actually do

Is industry doing enough for the climate – or are many efforts still largely plans on paper? A new study from Chalmers University of Technology examines how Sweden’s 20 largest industrial emitters are working toward the goal of net-zero emissions by 2045.

Image 1 of 1

The 20 largest industrial emitters account for nearly one third of Sweden’s greenhouse gas emissions. A new study from Chalmers University of Technology shows that companies’ climate ambitions do not always correspond to how actively they engage in transition projects. Illustration: AI-generated image / Chalmers.

Illustration Industry, energy transition, portrait Hans Hellsmark.

In the study Beyond leaders and laggards: How incumbents navigate transformative policy missions, published in the journal Energy Policy, the researchers examine how the largest emitters participate in government support programmes for the climate transition. The analysis draws on emissions statistics, project data from the Swedish Energy Agency’s Industrial Leap (Industriklivet) and the Swedish Environmental Protection Agency’s Climate Leap (Klimatklivet), as well as network analyses of collaborations between companies and other actors.

The results show that there is no clear link between high climate ambitions and concrete action.
“Large industrial companies are not only part of the climate problem – they are also an essential part of the solution,” says Hans Hellsmark, senior researcher in Environmental Systems Analysis at the Department of Technology Management and Economics at Chalmers University of Technology, and one of the researchers behind the study.

Some companies with ambitious climate targets participate in relatively few transition projects, while others – with less prominent targets – are highly active in initiatives such as hydrogen, electrification and carbon capture.

The study also shows that companies take on different roles in the transition: some drive technological breakthroughs, others build critical infrastructure, some test solutions step by step – and some remain fairly passive.

In Sweden, the 20 largest industrial emitters account for almost one third of the country’s total greenhouse gas emissions. At the same time, they are deeply embedded in the existing industrial system, with large facilities, long investment cycles and close links to suppliers, customers, regulations and politics.

“This means that their strategic choices – for example which technologies they invest in and which collaborations they enter into – are crucial for whether we actually succeed in reaching the climate targets,” says Hans Hellsmark.

The study analyses how industrial emitters engage with the two largest government support programmes for industrial climate transition: the Swedish Energy Agency’s Industriklivet and the Swedish Environmental Protection Agency’s Klimatklivet.

▶ Read more on the Swedish website 

FACTS:

The study ▶ “Beyond leaders and laggards: How incumbents navigate transformative policy missions” is publiched in the journal Energy Policy. 

Writers:
Hans Hellsmark Chalmers University of Technology
Johnn Andersson RISE Research Institutes of Sweden
Barbara Hedeler Chalmers University of Technology / AIT Austrian Institute of Technology

Hans Hellsmark

  • Senior Researcher, Innovation and R&D Management, Technology Management and Economics
To personal page

You may also be interested in

1 of 3

  • Mission-oriented policies with lessons from Nordic industry transformation
    research

    Mission-oriented policies with lessons from Nordic industry transformation

    Missions have become a popular approach among policymakers worldwide to tackle grand societal challenges, such as climate change. But it remains unclear how to design and implement policies to achieve such missions. In her doctoral thesis, Barbara Hedeler investigates the role of policymaking in achieving societal missions.

    Read more
  • Photovoltaics in the shade, despite opportunities
    climate

    Photovoltaics in the shade, despite opportunities

    The use of solar energy is growing in Sweden. But the photovoltaics panels mounted on Swedish rooftops and in solar parks are almost exclusively imported. New research from Chalmers University of Technology shows how Sweden could have had a domestic industry for production of photovoltaics. The lack of a clear national strategy is one of the reasons why it did not happen.

    Read more
  • Can the 70s oil crisis teach us about energy transition?
    energy

    Can the 70s oil crisis teach us about energy transition?

    Jessica Jewell blends technology and social sciences in her research. By studying historical energy transitions, she aims to discover which climate actions have the greatest potential for rapid implementation and impact. In the Verapodden podcast, she discusses economic and political factors that can both slow down and accelerate the transition of society, even though we know fairly well from a scientific perspective what needs to be done to reduce carbon dioxide emissions.

    Read more